Category Archives: Prisoner Votes

So I decided to rant about prisoners’ voting rights…

So, the prisoner votes issue is once again in the news, and right on cue we have the usual tired, disappointing arguments being bandied about.  David Cameron has shown a remarkable level of obstiance on the issue, stating that the idea of prisoners having the vote makes him ‘sick’ and that “prisoners are not getting the vote under this government”. The deadline for the government to bring forward legislative proposals is November 22nd, so it was expected that the issue would resurface, but I had hoped that the government would finally see sense. Silly me for being so naive.  The day after these comments, the issue was discussed on Question Time (watching QT is always a bad idea when human rights issues are likely to be discussed) and the treatment by the maority of panelists left me angry. Angry enough to resurrect this long dead blog. So, in the words of Faye Dunaway as Joan Crawford: let’s go.

My argument has two strands. Firstly, what the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) requires, following Scoppola v Italy (the most recent case, and the final attempt by the UK to change the Court’s mind), would not require huge changes, or complete enfranchisement of prisoners, so the political frenzy is not really justified.  Secondly, the idea that a blanket ban is acceptable reflects an incredibly out-dated, ultimately destructive view of criminal justice and why we punish people.

Continue reading

Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under Human Rights, Law, Prisoner Votes